The United States' National Infrastructure Protection Center (NIPC) has
posted an advisory
to its website, warning potentially "patriotic" hackers to keep their
exploits at bay.
Although Iraq itself has little connectivity to the Internet (aside from
several satellite connections in the Kurdish-controlled north), Iraqi
sympathizers in other countries are potential targets for hacktivism.
Hackers around the world have for years voiced an array of political views
through different types of hacktivism.
The February 11th advisory carries the United States' usual indifference to the
impetus behind a hacker's actions, but is the first to address hackers so
directly. "Regardless of the motivation," it reads, "the NIPC reiterates
such activity [hacking] is illegal and punishable as a felony."
Why would the U.S. government threaten to punish its own hackers for
targeting a supposed enemy? The NIPC offers just one argument in favor of
this strange position. Even patriotic hackers, it says, "can be fooled
into launching attacks against their own interests by exploiting malicious
code that purports to attack the other side when in fact it is designed to
attack the interests of the side sending it."
The NIPC advisory says that, by this notion, patriotic hackers risk
"becoming tools of their enemy." But the scenario is hardly realistic.
Sophisticated exploit tools allow their operators to specify individual
targets. They are not pre-programmed for a particular address. Patriotic
hackers in the U.S. are likely to select their targets carefully, from the
abundance of pro-Iraqi websites and e-mail hosts which exist on the
Internet today.
What then is the NIPC attempting to accomplish with this advisory? If the
U.S. has no desire to promote pro-Iraqi assets, then why the
apparent attempt to protect them? The answer could lie with the U.S.
government's own hackers, who may already be engaged in clandestine
operations against Iraq. If this is the case, any attention drawn by
hacktivism would indeed be highly undesirable.
Internet servers subjected to such overt tactics as hacktivism are often
thoroughly "swept out" in an attempt to evict the intruders -- intruders
who might include U.S. operatives from the CIA or the National Security
Agency.
The NIPC's advisory comes less than a week after President Bush ordered
development of what will be the country's first cyber-warfare doctrine.